Skip to main content

domain name system - Pushing DNSSEC updates with offline keys

In a non-professional capacity, I look after the DNS of
some 18 domains: mostly personal/vanity domains for immediate family. The whole shebang
is outsourced to an inexpensive managed hosting provider who have a web interface
through which I manage the zones.



These domains
are so unimportant that an attack targeted at them seems much less likely than a general
compromise of my provider's systems, at which point the records of all their customers
might be changed to misdirect traffic (perhaps with extremely long TTLs). DNSSEC could
mitigate such an attack, but only if the zones' private keys are not held by the hosting
provider.




So, I wonder:
how can one keep DNSSEC private keys offline yet still transfer signed
zones to an outsourced DNS
host?



The most obvious answer (to
me, at least) is to run one's own shadow/hidden master (from which the provider can
slave) and then copy offline-signed zonefiles to the master as
required.



The problem is that the only machine I
(want to*) control is my personal laptop, which usually connects
from a typical home ADSL (i.e. behind NAT over a dynamically-assigned IP address).
Having them slave from that (e.g. with a very long Expiry time
on the zone for periods when my laptop is offline/unavailable) would not only require a
dynamic DNS record from which they can slave (if indeed they can slave from a named host
rather than an explicit IP address), but would also involve me running a DNS server on
my laptop and opening both it and my home network up to the incoming zone transfer
requests: not ideal.



I would
prefer a much more push-oriented design, whereby my laptop
initiates transfer of offline-signed zonefiles/updates to the
provider.



I looked into whether
nsupdate could fit the bill: documentation is a little sketchy,
but my testing (with BIND 9.7) suggests it can indeed update DNSSEC zones, but only
where the server holds the keys to perform the zone signing; I have not found a way to
have it take an update including the relevant RRSIG/NSEC/etc. records and have the
server accept them. Is this a supported
use-case?




If not, I suspect the only
solutions which could fit the bill will involve non-DNS-based transfer of the zone
updates and would welcome recommendations that are supported by (hopefully inexpensive)
hosting providers: SFTP/SCP? rsync? RDBMS replication? Proprietary
API?



Finally, what would be the practical
implications of such a setup? Key rotation is jumping out at me as being an obvious
difficulty, especially if my laptop is offline for extended periods. But the zones are
extremely stable, so perhaps I could get away with long-lived
ZSKs**...?



/>

* Whilst I could run a shadow/hidden
master on e.g. an outsourced VPS, I dislike the overhead of having to secure / manage /
monitor / maintain yet another system; not to mention the additional financial costs of
so doing.



** Okay, this
would enable a determined attacker to replay expired records—but the risk and impact of
such are both tolerable in the case of these
domains.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

linux - iDRAC6 Virtual Media native library cannot be loaded

When attempting to mount Virtual Media on a iDRAC6 IP KVM session I get the following error: I'm using Ubuntu 9.04 and: $ javaws -version Java(TM) Web Start 1.6.0_16 $ uname -a Linux aud22419-linux 2.6.28-15-generic #51-Ubuntu SMP Mon Aug 31 13:39:06 UTC 2009 x86_64 GNU/Linux $ firefox -version Mozilla Firefox 3.0.14, Copyright (c) 1998 - 2009 mozilla.org On Windows + IE it (unsurprisingly) works. I've just gotten off the phone with the Dell tech support and I was told it is known to work on Linux + Firefox, albeit Ubuntu is not supported (by Dell, that is). Has anyone out there managed to mount virtual media in the same scenario?

hp proliant - Smart Array P822 with HBA Mode?

We get an HP DL360 G8 with an Smart Array P822 controller. On that controller will come a HP StorageWorks D2700 . Does anybody know, that it is possible to run the Smart Array P822 in HBA mode? I found only information about the P410i, who can run HBA. If this is not supported, what you think about the LSI 9207-8e controller? Will this fit good in that setup? The Hardware we get is used but all original from HP. The StorageWorks has 25 x 900 GB SAS 10K disks. Because the disks are not new I would like to use only 22 for raid6, and the rest for spare (I need to see if the disk count is optimal or not for zfs). It would be nice if I'm not stick to SAS in future. As OS I would like to install debian stretch with zfs 0.71 as file system and software raid. I have see that hp has an page for debian to. I would like to use hba mode because it is recommend, that zfs know at most as possible about the disk, and I'm independent from the raid controller. For us zfs have many benefits,

apache 2.2 - Server Potentially Compromised -- c99madshell

So, low and behold, a legacy site we've been hosting for a client had a version of FCKEditor that allowed someone to upload the dreaded c99madshell exploit onto our web host. I'm not a big security buff -- frankly I'm just a dev currently responsible for S/A duties due to a loss of personnel. Accordingly, I'd love any help you server-faulters could provide in assessing the damage from the exploit. To give you a bit of information: The file was uploaded into a directory within the webroot, "/_img/fck_uploads/File/". The Apache user and group are restricted such that they can't log in and don't have permissions outside of the directory from which we serve sites. All the files had 770 permissions (user rwx, group rwx, other none) -- something I wanted to fix but was told to hold off on as it wasn't "high priority" (hopefully this changes that). So it seems the hackers could've easily executed the script. Now I wasn't able